I want to offer some observations, and hopefully you'll be able to use those to decide whether you should get one.
1. The XB1 is NOT for kids...
Small children are getting access to game systems at younger ages. I'm not one to say they shouldn't have them around at all; I was playing Bloody Roar and Tekken with the guys long before conventional wisdom says I should have been.
But this console is far too powerful for your 7 year old.
Most of the allure lies in capabilities such as fantasy football, Skype, and advanced multitasking. Your kid doesn't need any of that. And you'll be spending more time trying to limit his/her access to various programs, versus enjoying the full capacity of the console.
You're better off getting a PS4 for your kid - or let them continue playing the 360 or PS3 that they undoubtedly already have. Games will continue being made for these consoles for a while, and you can rest easy.
2. ...but it can still have a permanent place in your living room for the family to enjoy.
Contradiction? Nope.
See, your kid doesn't need this console in their bedroom. They're not going to use it enough. But it CAN have a place in the living room, hooked up to the cable box.
It's a lot of fun shouting commands at the TV. No more searching for the controller when you want to change channels. You can navigate Netflix while laying cozy on the couch - or play DVDs, or watch TV, or switch between each.
Microsoft set out to make a console that everyone could enjoy at once, and they've really done a great job on that front. So if you want a device that will unify your living room and give you a unique viewing and interactive experience, this is it.
3. A lot of the features sound like gimmicks, until you use them.
When we took the console to my friend's house and told him about the voice commands, he boldly proclaimed that he wasn't interested in any of that, and just wanted to see gameplay.
An hour later, he was commanding the Xbox verbally just as much as we were.
![]() |
| When I pointed out what he was doing, he made this face. No lie. |
Our best comparison of voice controls comes from our smartphones, with services such as Siri and Google Now. So when we hear a console doing it, we think it's just as disposable as those are.
But it's a different integration of technology. And until you've actually seen it work, you have no idea of just how useful it is. As with the anecdote, once my friend realized that just saying a command is far easier and quicker than picking up a controller and navigating the screen, the choice to use his voice was simple.
Note: The voice commands are still inconsistent; sometimes they don't work. Sometimes they don't recognize you. It's gotten my requests wrong a few times. The technology isn't perfect. But the power is there.
4. If you're not willing to spend a little time setting it up, you're not going to make much use of it.
Anyone have an Android phone? You may have learned that the biggest difference between Android and iPhone is the amount of time it takes to set it up. It can literally take months with an Android before you've got it fully customized to your tastes, but after you've spent that time, you realize you truly have a device optimized to YOU, and life becomes much easier.
I tend to recommend Androids only to people who I know will spend the time to explore it. It's frustrating to someone who doesn't want to do that.
The same applies to the Xbox. Granted, you are given some concessions: if one person downloads apps, they are available to everyone to use, and there aren't many. But you need to spend some time tweaking your gamer pic, signing into all of your various accounts, and organizing your home screen. The Kinect needs to be calibrated. You need to let it know who you are so it can facially recognize you (a "gimmick" so useful that you're going to be upset next time you need to manually sign into your profile).
Once you've done the set up, the rest is simply letting it make life easier for you. But you have to put in a little work first.
5. This is the technology of the future - but it's not at it's best yet, so you're a bit of a beta tester.
This may be the deal breaker for some, and if it is, that's okay.
The XB1 isn't perfect. It has some lag issues (which have gotten better after spending some time with #4), and sometimes the voice commands don't work. But it is a machine full of potential.
You have to have some faith in that to appreciate it. You have to understand that this technology is going to take some time to really develop. But it will. Game developers will use the voice technology to add new dimensions to the game (Need for Speed Rivals is a fantastic example of the use of it). App developers will create programs for it, just as they had to do with phones. In a year or so, maybe even a few, this thing is going to blow everything we knew about technology out of the water.
Don't get the launch console unless you're okay with dealing with the bugs that come with that.
Don't even get it by Christmas. Wait until next year. It will still be more than worth it.
In conclusion -
If you're adventurous, interested in technology, and intrigued by the possibilities that await you, get an XB1. Maybe not now, but down the line, you're going to be glad you put this in your living room.
If you'd rather play it safe, want something specifically for your kids, or don't want to put much time into exploring, don't bother. Find someone who has one, see it in action in person, and if you find yourself going back to your entertainment system and missing it, then your decision has been made.
Did this help? Do you have one, or are you planning on getting it? Sound off below!




